Amazon Albums Reviews
THE
WHO - Tommy
(1969)
Tommy
(U.K.)
Tommy (U.S.)
The Who
Amazon.co.uk
Review:
Tommy had the dubious distinction of being the
first-ever rock opera; however, it's none the worse for
that, Ken Russell's adaptation notwithstanding. Due
largely to Pete Townshend's skill as a songwriter and
composer, Tommy tells a coherent story and
includes quality rock and roll at the same time, an
impressive feat by itself. While surprisingly more linear
than the later Quadrophenia, Tommy boasts several songs that stand up well on their own,
including the classic "Pinball Wizard", "The
Acid Queen", "I'm Free", and "Sally
Simpson". Much of the rest doesn't make much sense
lyrically unless you listen to the entire album, but
you'll probably want to do that anyway, preferably with
the lights low and the stereo cranked. --Genevieve
Williams
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.com
The
Who - Tommy Track Listing
Overture
It's A Boy
1921
Amazing Journey
Sparks
Eyesight To The Blind (The Hawker)
Christmas
Cousin Kevin
Acid Queen
Underture
Do You Think It's Alright
Fiddle About
Pinball Wizard
There's A Doctor
Go To The Mirror
Tommy
Can You Hear Me
Smash The Mirror
Sensation
Miracle Cure
Sally Simpson
I'm Free
Welcome
Tommy's Holiday Camp
We're Not Gonna Take It
|
The Who Page
The Who Live 8 Review
Classic Who Albums &
Compilations -
Comments & Track Listings
Live
At Leeds
Quadrophenia
Then
And Now
The Who Sell Out
Tommy
Who's Next
booksmusicfilmstv.com
1960s Music Index
booksmusicfilmstv.com
1970s Music Index
booksmusicfilmstv.com
1980s Music Index
booksmusicfilmstv.com
1990s to Contemporary Music Index
Audiobooks & Music from Amazon
TOMMY
- A HISTORY AND EXPLANATION OF THE ALBUM
Tommy (1969) is the first of The Who's two
full-scale rock operas (the second being Quadrophenia),
and the first musical work explicitly billed as a rock
opera. In some older publications it is called Tommy
(19141984). The opera was composed by Who
guitarist Pete Townshend, with two tracks contributed by
Who bassist John Entwistle and one fictitiously
attributed to Who drummer Keith Moon, though actually
written by Townshend. An earlier song by blues artist
Sonny Boy Williamson II was also incorporated into the
opera. Playing time is 74 minutes.
Synopsis
Characters
Tommy Walker: The protagonist of the
story.
Captain Walker: Tommy's father.
Mrs. Walker: Tommy's mother.
Uncle Ernie: Tommy's "wicked uncle",
a child molester.
Cousin Kevin: Tommy's cousin, the "school
bully".
The Hawker: The leader of a cult
religion.
The Champ: The reigning champion of a
pinball tournament, until Tommy defeats him and takes the
title of "Pinball Wizard"
The Acid Queen: A "gypsy" who
deals in hallucinogenic substances who attempts to heal
Tommy
The Doctor: A doctor who attempts to
heal Tommy and finds out that his disabilities are all in
his head.
Sally Simpson: One of Tommy's "disciples".
Story - in chronological order
"Overture"/"It's a Boy" - British
Army Captain Walker is reported missing in action during
World War I, and is not expected ever to be seen again.
Shortly after his wife, Mrs. Walker, receives this news,
she gives birth to their son, Tommy.
"1921" - Seven years later, Captain Walker
returns home and discovers that his wife has found a new
lover. An enraged Captain Walker confronts his wife and
kills her new lover. To cover up the crime, Tommy's
mother and father tell him he didn't see it, didn't hear
it, and he will never say "nothing to no one ever in
[his] life". A traumatized Tommy takes this
literally, becoming deaf, dumb, and blind.
"Amazing Journey"/"Sparks" - Tommy's
subconscious reveals itself to him as a tall stranger
dressed in silvery robes with a golden floor-length
beard, and the vision sets him on an internal spiritual
journey upon which he learns to interpret all physical
sensations as music.
"Eyesight to the Blind (The Hawker)" - Tommy's
parents take him to a the church of a cult religion to
try and cure him. "Eyesight..." is the cult
leader's song.
"Christmas" - Tommy's parents worry that his
soul is at risk of damnation, since he is unaware of
Jesus or prayer.
"Cousin Kevin" - Tommy's parents become
complacent and leave him in the care of a babysitter, his
cousin Kevin. Kevin takes the opportunity to bully and
torture Tommy without fear of anyone finding out. He
ultimately gets bored with Tommy's limited reactions.
"Acid Queen"/"Underture" - Tommy's
parents once again try to cure him, this time by placing
him in the care of a woman who tries to coax Tommy into
full consciousness with hallucinogenic drugs. "Underture"
is an extensive instrumental representing Tommy's
experience on acid.
"Do You Think it's Alright?"/"Fiddle About"
- Tommy is left in the care of his uncle Ernie, an
alcoholic sexual deviant who takes the opportunity to
abuse Tommy without fear of anyone finding out.
"Pinball Wizard" - Tommy is discovered to have
a talent for pinball, and quickly defeats the game's
tournament champion. This propels Tommy to international
celebrity status. "Pinball Wizard" is the
reigning champion's song.
"There's a Doctor"/"Go to the Mirror!"
- Tommy's parents find a medical specialist to once more
try to understand and cure his symptoms. After numerous
tests, they are told that there is nothing medically
wrong with him, and that his problems are psychosomatic.
However, as they are trying to reach him, Tommy's
subconscious is also trying to reach out to them.
"Tommy Can You Hear Me?"/"Smash the Mirror"
- Tommy's mother continues to try to reach him, and
becomes frustrated that he completely ignores her whilst
staring directly at a mirror. Out of this frustration she
smashes the mirror.
"Sensation"/"Miracle Cure" - The
smashing of the mirror snaps Tommy out of his unreceptive
state. Tommy's cure becomes a public sensation and he
attains guru-like status. Thereafter he assumes a quasi-messianic
mantle and tries to lead his fans to an enlightenment
similar to his own.
"Sally Simpson" - One of Tommy's 'disciples',
Sally is a young reverend's daughter who sneaks out of
her home to attend one of Tommy's sermons. She ultimately
attempts to touch him, only to be thrown from the stage
by security and receive a gash on her face.
"I'm Free" - Tommy attempts to spiritually
enlighten those that are listening to his sermons.
"Welcome"/"Tommy's Holiday Camp" -
Tommy opens his own home to anyone willing to join him,
and urges them to bring as many people with them as they
can. His house is quickly filled though, so he builds a
holiday camp to try to accommodate everybody.
"We're Not Gonna Take It" - Tommy demands that
his followers blind, deafen and mute themselves in order
to truly reach their spiritual height, but the heavy-handedness
of his cult and the exploitation of its followers by his
family and associates cause his followers to revolt
against him. Abandoned by his followers and worshippers,
Tommy gains a new enlightenment.
OR
"We're Not Gonna Take It" could be a metaphoric
representation of people "not taking" such
rigid, religious and capitalistic, views that society
forces upon us. The people agree with Tommy's philosophy
that we should put in our ear plugs and put on our
nightshades when society attempts to train us in such
ways. We should thus, ultimately, follow our own insight,
as Tommy did/does throughout this story. Therefore, the
people see that "looking at you" (looking at
Tommy) they see the "music" (they see/understand
the beauty of it all). They see that enlightenment stems
from within yourself, and often not from what you have
been taught is true.
In its original album version, the story is quite
sketchy, and details were often filled in post facto by Townshend in interviews. As other adaptations of the
album appeared, some details were filled out and others
were changed (for example the time frame was changed to
World War II and 1951 in some later versions and in the
film version, the lover kills the husband rather than the
converse).
Analysis and history
When Tommy was released, critics were split
between those who thought the album was a masterpiece,
the beginnings of a new genre, and those that felt it was
"sick" and exploitative because of its dark
theme. The album was banned by the BBC and certain U.S.
radio stations. Ultimately, the album became a huge
commercial success, as did the Who's frequent live
performances of the rock opera in the following years,
arguably launching the Who to an essentially new level of
prestige and international stardom.
Although Tommy is conventionally described as a
rock opera, author and Who historian Richard Barnes
points out that this definition is not strictly correct,
since Tommy does not utilise the classic
operatic formulae of staging, scenery, acting and
recitative. According to Barnes, Tommy could be
more accurately described as a "rock cantata"
or a "rock song cycle".
Musically, the original album is a complex set of pop-rock
arrangements, generally based upon Townshend's acoustic
guitar and built up with many overdubs by the four
members of the band using many instruments, including
bass, electric and acoustic guitars, piano, organ,
drumkit, gong, timpani, horn, three-part vocal harmonies
and occasional doubling on vocal solos. Despite this
instrumental richness the sound tends to be very "stark",
especially in comparison to the band's later work. Many
of the instruments only appear intermittently -- the ten-minute
"Underture" features a single toot on the horn
-- and when overdubbed many of the instruments are mixed
at low levels that require careful listening to notice.
Townshend mixes fingerpicking in with his trademark power
chords and fat riffs, and in some delicate moments his
guitar sounds almost like a harpsichord. Moon's drumming
is controlled with a few dramatic moments; Entwistle's
bass provides support and effectively takes the
instrumental lead in several cuts. Daltrey swaggers as
lead vocalist, but shares that role with the others on a
surprising number of tracks. Townshend's later interest
in synthesizers is foreshadowed by the use of taped
sounds played in reverse to give a whistling, chirping
sound on "Amazing Journey."
"Amazing Journey" can be interpreted as the
central pivot of Tommy, since its lyrics are
essential to understanding what the opera is about (beyond
the facile story line). "Go to the Mirror" is
the climax of the opera both musically and dramatically;
tradition holds that when the band was touring the show
live the audiences would spontaneously stand up during
"Go to the Mirror" and remain standing until
the endlistening in silence, unlike the customary
behavior of Who fans. "We're Not Gonna Take It / See
Me, Feel Me / Listening to You" is the denouement,
with its ambiguous return to the earlier state of the
story reinforced in concert by returning to the riff from
"Overture" and "Go to the Mirror" at
the very end rather than the long fade from the studio
recording. Various themes are repeated in different songs
in order to give the opera a coherent feel.
The tracks "Overture", "Pinball Wizard",
"I'm Free", and the "See Me, Feel Me /
Listening to You" reprise were released as singles
and got a decent amount of airplay. "Pinball Wizard"
reached the top twenty in the U.S. and the top five in
the UK. "See Me, Feel Me / Listening To You"
landed high in the top twenty in the U.S. and "I'm
Free" reached the top forty. The tracks "Overture",
"Christmas", "Im Free", and
"See Me Feel Me" were released on an EP in late
1970. The "Overture" was also covered by a band
called The Assembled Multitude and received a lot of
airplay. Tommy was inducted into the Grammy Hall
of Fame in 1998.
The child abuse that features so prominently in the story
caused a good deal of outcry when it was first released.
It has often been claimed that the basic idea of the Tommy story was lifted from The Pretty Things' 1968
concept album S.F. Sorrow, and Townshend himself
later admitted that he listened to the Pretty Things LP
extensively and that it was a major inspiration for Tommy.
Steve Marriott also claimed that some musical elements in Tommy were "borrowed" from the music
of The Small Faces. Christian rock pioneer Larry Norman,
in his official biography, states that "Pete
Townshend credited Larry's own rock-opera, The Epic,
for inspiring the rock-opera, Tommy, recorded by
The Who". Notwithstanding the numerous outside
influences, several structural precedents for Tommy exist
in Townshend's own work, including "Glow Girl"
(1968), "Rael" (1967), and the sectional work
"A Quick One While He's Away" (1966).
A couple of years before the album came out Pete
Townshend explained his ideas and apparently actually
thought out some of the structure of the opera during a
famous Rolling Stone interview. John Entwistle
claimed years after the release that he had never
actually listened to the album because he was so sick of
it after the endless takes and re-takes.
Personnel
Roger Daltrey: Lead Vocals, Harmonica
Pete Townshend: Guitars, Keyboards, Vocals
John Entwistle: Bass guitar, Horns, Vocals
Keith Moon: Drums, Percussion, Vocals
Paul Townshend (Pete's brother): Backing Vocals
Simon Townshend (Pete's brother): Backing Vocals
Retrieved from "Tommy
(rock opera) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia"
All
text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License (see Copyrights for details).
Privacy policy |